Conference Review - Medicine at the Margins: Creative Solutions to Healthcare Challenges

Print Email

Edinburgh Banner

The Medical Women’s Federation Spring Conference, 'Medicine at the Margins: Creative Solutions to Healthcare Challenges', took place on Friday 13th May 2016 at the John McIntyre Conference Centre Edinburgh. This is situated within the Pollock Halls of Residence and has a very scenic backdrop with Arthur’s seat very close by.

Our first speaker was Dr Christine Goodall OBE, a senior lecturer and honorary consultant oral surgeon at Glasgow University who founded the charity Medics against Violence (MAV) in 2008. Due to their educational programmes reaching those in primary and secondary schools, youth clubs and prisons, there has been a reduction in homicide and serious assault in Scotland. Behaviours which can lead to what she termed ‘recreational violence’, such as excessive drinking and knife carrying, have also reduced in the younger age group, who have participated in the programme whilst at school. She described other ‘teachable moments’ as being parenting, when assaulted, when arrested and when convicted. MAV also runs the Navigator programme at Glasgow Royal Infirmary which follows up A&E attenders who have presented due to violence, drugs, alcohol, homelessness and domestic or sexual violence. Another programme started in 2010 is Ask, Support, Care (ASC) and trains all health professionals including dentists, vets, fire officers and hairdressers to recognise and respond to signs of domestic abuse. (Non accidental injury to a victim’s pet can be a feature of domestic violence.) Domestic abuse is estimated to affect 1 in 4 women in Scotland and has significant health and social consequences.

MWF 14 05 2016 Edinburgh Paresh Solanki 5

Next, Dr Rosie Hague described her career which led to her becoming the first consultant in paediatric infectious diseases and immunology in Scotland and thus responsible for setting up the service. This began with an elective in Nepal and going in to Paediatrics when she failed to get the Obstetrics job she wanted. The AIDs epidemic in the 1980s sparked her interest in the transmission of the disease from mother to child and her research led her to posts in Newcastle and Denver Colorado before returning to a consultant post in Edinburgh. She told us about the discovery of the methods which have reduced HIV transmission from mother to child from 25% to 1-2% and the testing regime for the baby to reach a diagnosis as early as possible. For those children who are found to be HIV positive, appropriate treatment regimes were devised. There is still stigma around HIV, particularly amongst African women and because breast feeding is almost universal in this group, she feels that many of them continue to breast feed against advice because not to do so leads to an assumption that the mother is HIV positive. As HIV is now a chronic disease the timing of disclosure to the child about their condition is important and as they become teenagers they need counselling about their sexuality. Besides infectious diseases Dr Hague has an interest in primary immune deficiencies and concluded her talk with hope for the future.

MWF 14 05 2016 Edinburgh Paresh Solanki 6

The first abstract was presented by Dr Yesim Karapinar who, having spent precious time trying to locate the equipment she needed to cannulate a patient on a strange ward, came up with the idea of procedure specific trays in treatment rooms. The second abstract from Dr Jacqueline Andrews told us about the Leeds Female Leaders Network set up for women to inspire each other whilst working towards gender equality in the workplace and leadership positions.

Alison Cameron, Leadership Associate at the Kings Fund gave a very personal account of her descent in to loss of career, alcohol abuse and homelessness after a diagnosis of PTSD which followed the deaths of 2 of her colleagues whilst they were working on a project in Russia connected with the Chernobyl disaster. She asked us to think about how we describe ourselves. Is it by the title of our job? What then happens if this is taken away as happened to her? She is a believer in shared decision making in medicine because this empowers the patient not only to make decisions about their own care but to have a wider role in the development of health care policies. Self management was her own starting point to recovery and she now advises health and social care organisations including NHS England on how to work in partnership with those who use the service.

MWF 14 05 2016 Edinburgh Paresh Solanki 35

Miss Elaine Griffiths, Chair of the Medical Royal Colleges Flexible Training Committee presented the results of the recent Parental Leave Survey. The responses highlighted that most trainees were straight back in after returning from a period of parental leave with no shadowing and that departmental changes are not being communicated to those on leave which can lead to difficulties on their return. Facilities for breast feeding mothers were found to be lacking. Many commented that they were not allowed to use the rooms allocated for the use of patients but were expected to express breast milk with little privacy or in the toilet. The survey also highlighted that very few male trainees have taken parental leave.

After lunch we had a choice of three workshops to encourage active participation and discussion. These were
- ‘The Show must go on – Health and the Performing Artists’
- ‘It’s a family disease – living with alcoholism’
- ‘Old Docs, New Tricks? Working Longer’

MWF 14 05 2016 Edinburgh Paresh Solanki 100

Another inspirational talk followed, from Ann Maxwell OBE, Co-founder of the Muir Maxwell Trust which has raised £9m since 2003 to both raise awareness of complex childhood epilepsies, and to give practical support to children and families struggling to cope with epilepsy (such as the provision of night time alarms to detect seizures). She described it as ‘a field that chose me’ as her youngest child Muir has severe epilepsy. She has continued to work towards her goal of seeing better outcomes for the children coming behind her son despite being diagnosed herself with a craniochondrosarcoma in 2006.

Our next speaker was Philippa Whitford, a consultant breast surgeon and since 2014 MP for Central Ayrshire sitting on the Parliamentary Health Select Committee. As well as talking about her experiences as an MP and the usefulness of her mobile phone as a tracking device for her husband to time meals when she is working from home, and FaceTime calls when she is in London, she told us about her 2 trips to Gaza. The blockade has had considerable impact on the treatment and survival of women with breast cancer. Continuous supplies of drugs including chemotherapy are unreliable and at 40% the survival rate is half what it is here. Over treatment with surgery due to poor access to diagnostic services and radiotherapy means many women are left with disabling lymphoedema.

MWF 14 05 2016 Edinburgh Paresh Solanki 68

Prizes were awarded for the abstracts to both presenters. The poster prize was won by Dr Alice Howe, FY1 North Devon District Hospital for ‘Together we can end female genital mutilation; our new statutory obligations under the amended female genital mutilation act 2003 (sections 70-75 of the serious crime act 2015) explained’. The Katherine Branson Essay Prize winners were Helena Fawdry, 3rd year student at Liverpool university, and Karthika Velusamy, 4th year student at Leeds.

We ended the day with the Dame Hilda Rose Memorial Lecture ‘The Importance of Women’ given by Dr Catherine Calderwood, the Chief Medical Officer of Scotland. She reminded us that Dame Hilda Rose remains the only woman to have been President of the Royal College of Obstetrics and Gynaecology. She began by talking about some pioneering women in medicine beginning with Dr James Barrie who graduated from Edinburgh University in 1812 and was an outstanding Army Surgeon. Only on his death from dysentery in 1865 was he found to be a woman, a fact not made public for 100 years. She moved on to talk about women as patients today, their physiological differences from men, unique diseases and the importance of the health of women to that of the next generation. Clinical trials of drugs often exclude women yet the results are extrapolated and fail to account for the gender differences in pathophysiology. This may contribute to poorer outcomes in women. Diseases which only affect women such as endometriosis do not attract the same resources and research as those that affect both sexes but can have a significant effect on families and working days lost. Many adult diseases have their developmental origins in the womb for example cardiovascular disease in the offspring of obese mothers, thus the future health of the whole nation becomes dependent on the health of women of chid bearing age. Perinatal depression, the commonest complication of pregnancy has also been shown to influence the mental health of the child in later life. She concluded by reminding us that maternity leave was not introduced until 1971. In a profession now dominated by women she considered the barriers to positions of leadership and encouraged us to take as example the V formation of flying geese. Different specialties inevitably demand different attributes and some will remain more suited to men, however the opportunities should be equal.

MWF 14 05 2016 Edinburgh Paresh Solanki 140

The meeting was followed by the AGM and then our new President Dr Parveen Kumar gave her Presidential address. Whilst considering the future challenges of the MWF going forward her quote ‘If you educate a man you educate a person, if you educate a woman you educate a whole family’ seemed to reflect on the themes of the day.

On the Thursday evening prior to the conference several members met at ‘Spoon’ for an informal supper. The conference dinner was held at the John McIntyre conference centre and was followed by a ceilidh band which got some of us up and dancing!

Judy Booth 

Medical Women's Federation
Tavistock House North,
Tavistock Square, London,
Tel: 020 7387 7765

Follow us on Twitter

Early Bird registration for our Autumn Conference ends on 10th Sept. Book now to avoid disappointment.
Join us in continuing our #MWFCentenary celebrations at our November Conference on Friday 3rd November:…
Aug 19replyretweet